As Xenophobic as South Africans
No one hates foreigners like South Africans do. South Africa is said to be officially the most xenophobic nation in the world. So much for being xenophobic and all that but why go to the criminal extent of murdering about 50 immigrants? South Africa’s President Thabo Mbeki was reported to have described the saga as “disgraceful” but I say it is far more than disgraceful. It is outrightly criminal and those behind the attacks must be prosecuted to the full extent of the law!
I put the blame of the criminal attacks fully at the doorstep of the South African government. I’d quote excerpts of a recent article by Rowan Philip published in The Times aptly titled: “No one hates foreigners like we do“.
Responding to the shock findings, political analyst Moeletsi Mbeki, brother of President Thabo Mbeki, blamed the government’s “failure to acknowledge the crisis in Zimbabwe, failure to control the borders, and failure to grant these people refugee status” as the “real reason” for levels of xenophobia and the past month’s violence.
[...]
Instead, University of Pretoria Professor Hussein Solomon, former immigrants project head for the Institute for Security Studies, said attitudes stemmed from “perhaps the most lopsided regional economics in the world”, in which, per capita, Mozambicans earn 36 times less than South Africans, and Zimbabweans far less than that.
“When the economy turned sour here, it was always going to happen — inevitable, but also predictable, and the government has failed to act to counter it,” said Solomon.
[...]
“The Mbeki government’s refusal,” according to Solomon, to respond to the scale of the migration with any national policy, as well as the withholding of police statistics on the involvement of foreigners in crime;
[...]
# The failure of the government to heed isolated xenophobic attacks and regular warnings from the SA Human Rights Commission, Idasa and the National Intelligence Agency; and# “A perpetuation of negative stereotypes of migrants in the South African press” — and from public figures — according to a major report by Queens University, Canada, and Samp, which found that 52% of press reports on migration from 2000 to 2003 included negative references to migrants.
Show me a great nation, and I will show you a nation where immigrants have played a significant role in the development of that nation’s economic development. No single nation can do it alone.
This serious attack on foreigners in addition to the recent power crisis is making me wonder: is this Rainbow nation on the brink of an implosion? So much for African Union and all that…




May 27th, 2008 at 7:37 pm
With this incidence, how really true is it that SA is the “rainbow” nation? I grieve, and have lacked words to express this.
May 27th, 2008 at 7:44 pm
“Rainbow nation” refers to the shades of races in that country. I agree with you that this terrible incident is very grievous indeed and has dented the image of South Africa in no small measure.
May 28th, 2008 at 4:44 am
[...] ????? ?? ???? ?????? ????? ?? ???? ????? ????? ?? ???? ?????? ???: “????????? ?? ????? ???? ?????? [...]
May 28th, 2008 at 9:11 am
[...] David Ajao dia mihevitra fa ny governemanta no tompon'andraikitra voalohany amin'ny herisetra sy fanafihana vahiny mpiavy m… any Afrika Atsimo : No one hates foreigners like South Africans do. South Africa is said to be [...]
Jun 1st, 2008 at 6:07 am
No one hates foreigners like South Africans do. South Africa is said to be officially the most xenophobic nation in the world.
Wow, where did you get that impression (besides the recent events)?
I live in SA since 4 months now, and never did I even have the idea that Southafricans might be xenophobic. So many ppl here are somehow from abroad. I study at the UCT with about 80 ppl from foreign countries, and no-one has ever even mentioned that they experienced any kind of unfriendlyness.
Jun 5th, 2008 at 9:20 am
I have been labeled as a white middle-class male who happens to live in South Africa. I have a secure job and have not been directly affected in anyway by the ‘xenophobia crisis.’ You can call me indifferent, or a “privileged white”, but never associate me with South Africans that torture their fellow human being.
Give this a read: Debunking xenophobia - about the South African mind-set
Jun 5th, 2008 at 10:48 am
I enjoyed reading your blog post Galen. You summed it all up by stating that you’re a “priviledged white”. To a reasonable extent, you’re immune from the xenophobic madness.
@ robg, please read The Times article I linked to.
Jun 17th, 2008 at 8:04 am
i can say is the our goverment who is the couse of xenophobia,1 they say every one who live in SA have the right ti shelter ect.that way the come for they rest of their live in SA,they goverment must have the limits to foreing,as well as the camp for them and work on repairing the boards